Do you remember when the National Geographic Society unveiled the Gospel of Judas a couple of years ago? The newly discovered document supposedly contained a positive portrayal of Judas Iscariot, the man whom the canonical Gospels say betrayed Jesus.
The Chronicle of Higher Education has a story about the aftermath of National Geographic’s unveiling, and it is not a pretty picture.
‘When the Gospel of Judas was unveiled at a news conference in April 2006, it made headlines around the world â€” with nearly all of those articles touting the new and improved Judas. “In Ancient Document, Judas, Minus the Betrayal,” read the headline in The New York Times. The British paper The Guardian called it “a radical makeover for one of the worst reputations in history.” A documentary that aired a few days later on National Geographic’s cable channel also pushed the Judas-as-hero theme. The premiere attracted four million viewers, making it the second-highest-rated program in the channel’s history, behind only a documentary on September 11.
‘But almost immediately, other scholars began to take issue with the interpretation . . . of the National Geographic team. They didn’t see a good Judas at all. In fact, this Judas seemed more evil than ever. Those early voices of dissent have since grown into a chorus, some of whom argue that National Geographic’s handling of the project amounts to scholarly malpractice. It’s a perfect example, critics argue, of what can happen when commercial considerations are allowed to ride roughshod over careful research. What’s more, the controversy has strained friendships in this small community of religion scholars â€” causing some on both sides of the argument to feel, in a word, betrayed.’
So much for scholarly objectivity.
“The Gospel of Judas: A Transparent Fiction” – April 8, 2006
“The Gospel according to Judas Debunked” – December 19, 2007
Has National Geographic ever addressed these concerns? Maybe a letter to the readers or something? I haven’t found anything or read anything (I subscribe).
I allowed a ten-year subscription to NG to lapse because of the way they handled the Judas incident. Wrote and told them why I was doing so. Never heard word one back from them.
D. Taylor Benton
What is even more shocking is the whole “tomb of Jesus” stuff that was even a movie i believe made about it…it was great to see I believe 60 minutes run a follow up story on the discovery and it was exposed that the man the “had” the cask or “box” that had the inscription was a phony and he was being investigated by several countries in counterfeiting artifacts along with he was convicted and being charged by Egypt in counterfeiting…..this somehow went under the radar which is about par for the course.