Christianity,  Complementarianism,  Egalitarianism,  Theology/Bible

What Happened at the Evangelical Theological Society?

I write a round-up every year after the annual meeting of the Evangelical Theological Society. This is admittedly a topic of probably limited interest to general readers. But to all the theo-nerds out there who may be reading, this one’s for you. I hope you feel seen.

1. The CBMW banquet was on Monday night at Fogo de Chão in downtown Denver this year. I was asked to be the keynote and to speak on a topic related to my new book Mere Complementarianism. I made the case for mere complementarianism, which isn’t minimal complementarianism. Rather, it’s a thoroughgoing recognition that God created men and women different, and those differences have implications for the home, the church, and everywhere men and women can be found. I also talked about challenges to the teaching from soft complementarianism and from some sectors of so-called “biblical patriarchy.”

I can’t say that the talk was amazing, but the food sure was good! Much thanks to Jonathan Woodyard and Southwest Baptist University for their generous support of this event.

2. On Tuesday morning, I participated on a panel reviewing Preston Sprinkle’s new book From Genesis to Junia: An Honest Search for What the Bible Really Says About Women in Leadership (David C Cook). Here is the panel listed in the order you see pictured above:

  • Denny Burk – Complementarian
  • Gerry Breshears – Soft Complementarian (moderator)
  • Mimi Haddad – Egalitarian
  • Cynthia Westfall – Egalitarian
  • Preston Sprinkle – Egalitarian

We each delivered a 25-minute review of the book followed by a 25-minute response from Preston. Then we had a 40-minute panel discussion/debate about the issue. I’ll make two comments about this event.

First, I really enjoyed the engagement. Even though the panel was supposed to be about Preston’s book, when the panel discussion started, the three egalitarians directed their questions to me. Which was totally fine by me. I appreciate the opportunity to get in the weeds with real live egalitarians. It’s much more productive to do these kinds of discussions in person than sounding off on social media. There were a couple points I wish I had been sharper on, but overall I’m grateful for the opportunity to contribute.

Second, I continue to be struck by the differences between my “mere complementarianism” and so-called “soft complementarianism.” The soft complementarian view really does seem to be functional egalitarianism with the one exception that women cannot hold the office of elder. Otherwise, there may be little difference between an egalitarian church and a soft-complementarian church in terms of who actually teaches and leads the congregation.

Third, I really appreciated engaging with my fellow panelists. Even though the dynamic was a little unbalanced (basically three against one with Breshears mainly moderating), I would do it again in a heartbeat. In spite of our disagreements, I genuinely like my fellow panelists and hope we can do it again some time.

3. On Wednesday, I attended a session that included stimulating papers from both Preston Sprinkle and Dani Treweek. In his paper, Preston argued that soft-complementarianism is an untenable position (which I heartily agree with), but he argued for it in a way that I was not expecting.

He observed that it is common among soft-complementarians to limit the office of overseer/elder to men but to treat to role of “pastor” not as an office but as a gift (which I have written about previously here). Preston argues that the idea of their being “offices” in the church is foreign to the new testament. Rather, God gifts both men and women for all kinds of ministry, and all are welcome to participate in teaching and leadership (at least I think that’s the gist of it).

In the Q&A, I decided to give a some pushback on the idea that the New Testament doesn’t know anything of the concept of “office.” Office is simply the word we use to describe the fact that people can be installed in positions of authority to accomplish a certain task within a jurisdiction. Even if the English word “office” isn’t used in the Greek New Testament, the concept of “office” certainly is there. For example, the use of the Greek term episcopēs in 1 Timothy 3:1 and Acts 1:20 is often translated with the English word “office.” Why? Because both indicate someone filling an office that requires them to exercise oversight.

There was much more that I disagreed with in Preston’s presentation. He’s an egalitarian, so that’s no surprise. But the only point we engaged on related to the question of “offices” within the church.

4. Jim Hamilton moderated a session on the translation of monogenēs in John’s writings, and it was the most interesting session I attended all week. The panel debated whether monogenēs should be translated as “only begotten” (as in the KJV and NASB) or “only” (as in the ESV and many other modern English versions)?

Of particular interest to me was the inclusion of Vern Poythress on the panel. He is an ESV translator and one of the main reasons that the ESV has rendered monogenēs as “only.” I was surprised that Poythress did not defend the ESV’s translation at all. He simply discussed some of the evidence and concluded that the matter is very complicated and difficult. I thought he would defend the ESV’s translation, but he didn’t.

Charles Lee Irons and Travis Wright were the other two panelists, and they both gave overwhelming linguistic evidence demonstrating that “only begotten” is the most accurate translation. I was dialed-in on both of those excellent papers.

For reasons I have elaborated elsewhere, I agree with Irons and Wright that monogenēs should be translated “only begotten,” and it’s past time for English translations to go back to the traditional rendering. It matters for the doctrine of eternal generation, and English versions should stop concealing from readers that monogenēs denotes begetting.

5. I attended John Dickson’s plenary session on Thursday morning. For those of you who are not familiar with John Dickson, he’s the Australian scholar who has written a book attempting to give exegetical warrant for women to preach to the congregation. That view has been growing in recent years in ostensibly “complementarian” churches and has become a major plank in the soft-complementarian argument.

Even though this was not the subject of Dickson’s address, I still wanted to hear him. I now understand why he is such an influencer in Australia and beyond. He’s a master communicator. He’s funny, wry, and smart—an absolute dazzler behind the lectern. Go listen to him, and see for yourself.

6. Fred Sanders was elected vice-president in the business session, which means that he is in line to be president of ETS after David Pao and Gwenfair Adams. Fred is an outstanding scholar and will do really well in this role. I was really pleased to see him get the nod from the nominating committee.

There is so much more that happened at ETS than I have captured here. This is simply what things were like from my point of view. For me, it’s a highlight every year, and I’m looking forward to next year’s meeting in Washington, D.C.

Thank you for visiting DennyBurk.com

Enter your e-mail below to receive my posts directly to your inbox.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.